Monday, July 2, 2007

Let's kick this off.

The idea behind this blog is to explore the reports by Europeans, Russians and others that America is seriously lacking in the sociality department. For a good example of the basis behind these claims, I'd reccomend reading Winston Wu's E-book at http://www.happierabroad.com/ebook/Contents.htm. While I don't agree with many of his wild notions, like the way he seems to blaim feminism for things, or how he makes sweeping generalizations from his own anecdotes, he does write some very interesting points worth summarizing, his views are:

Americans huddle in cliques, even after high-school.

Americans are highly distrustful of people outside their clique or circle of friends.

It's socially unacceptable to meet people you don't know in a normal atmosphere (grocery stores, shops, etc) whereas this is common-place in Europe / Russia and other countries.

"Breaking the ice" is just a term invented by Americans, and it doesn't require nearly as much effort elsewhere.

There is enormous peer pressure to conform to specific images and archetypes created by pop-culture, and that it's not nearly as bad in other countries as in the USA.

We try to boost ourselves with fake optimism, afraid people will see our faults, and this makes us socially insecure.

Even normal, non-assuming men get stigmatized as "creepy" if they try to approach a woman they don't know outside of a club / party / social setting, but this is normal behavior abroad. (Personally, I think this is a good example of Winston Wu being too subjective again. Anybody can come off as 'creepy' if you approach someone too strongly. However, this seems to be one of his thesis points in the book.)

It's more socially acceptable in Europe for men to be regular-friends with women, so women don't automatically assume men are trying to pick them up, therefore it's easier to chat and casually date.

Because of these points and other things, he says the dating scene in the U.S is far more difficult and awkward.

Winston also says Americans are extremely isolated and believe that the 95% of the rest of the world behave as they do, with their same tendencies, but this is a total myth.

I think Winston is looking at the rest of the world through somewhat rose-tinted glasses, because there are some human traits which you just can't get away from. However, I'm willing to bet some of these social problems are much, much worse here in the states.

What I found fascinating is that I never noticed these things until I started talking to European exchange students, and I noticed the drastic personality differences. While most Americans I know are shut off around people in public, Europeans seem quick to engage people in a very inclusive way, even in unlikely places. So, what can we learn from them?

In addition to trying to find a multi-cultural array of people to interview for this blog, the regular people I talk to around our bleak little town of Tucson, AZ will work as an experiment in itself: How receptive will people in non-social environments be to someone talking to them (and not trying to sell something)? How many people will ignore me, react with hostility, or how many people will be friendly and open to conversation? How many people will mace me in the face or tazer me in the balls? How much of an ass of myself could I potentially make? Most of these are very important pieces of data.

Other things I may do: See if adults really do pack together in cliques by doing things like interviewing the gaggles (is that a word?) of blonde-haired girls at my college, and other people who seem socially uniformed. I will also examine popular culture and TV and see if it really discourages diversifying your social life. Could American pop-culture be the source of scorn against so-called "nerds" and other people classified as "uncool" by most of our society?

All I ask is that you subscribe to this blog, and check for updates, so that my work won't be in vain. Thank you!

3 comments:

Truthfulinsights said...

Good blog and very true. Some notes:

1)The coldness of America is in stark contrast to how Americans view themselves, though. Most see themselves as open, informal, non chalant and hospitable/helpful.
2)Anti-socialness is relative. The Japanese love Americans for being 'very' social and friendly. In Japan talking to strangers is many times more of a taboo so Americans are seen as these passionate, Latin-like people. Brits also find Americans hospitable and open. Russians, and Mexicans suffer in the US very much, though.
Compared to a corpse, a paraplegic is a warm friendly person, but not compared to a living/breathing being.
3) Is it the American thing or is it the Anglo Saxon thing? I found NZ to be the same.
4) French Canadians talk to strangers and it is very nice there and very social. So, it may not be climate per se.
5) Is the whole thing an Anglo/Germanic thing?

D. Douglas Graham said...

We're mean.

Don't buy it?

Below you will find my phone number. I dare you, any of you, to call.

I post this piece of highly personal information with the certainty that no one will take up the challenge. Should any one of you grow a sufficient amount of below-the-belt fortitude to actually do this, please post your own phone number someplace else so that another brave soul will get the opportunity to show the chickenshit citizenry of this declining republic what he or she is made of.

Viva la Revolucion!

314-394-0371.

David said...

This is one of the most interesting blogs I have read on the Internet. I think that the more intelligent, open, and informal among us and visitors to our shores seem to be able to spark a conversation anywhere. I recently talked with a minister about the Mayan calendar date of 12/21/2012 and its religious significance at a hospital I visited. With the lack of education in the country and the confusion of science with psudo-religion doctrine, I believe many Americans are not functioning members of society but are only going through the motions. In many school systems in Mississippi, the dropout rate is 50% or more. And the schools cook the books on the figures even then. Most colleges, universities, and employers have extensive job training programs to bring them up to High School graduate levels.
In other societies, you are part of that society and you have health care, old age pension, generous vacation benefits, state benefits we could only wonder at, etc., while we in America have to earn every single dime of our way. It makes us hard, doubtful of others, and distrustful of society as a whole.